This factsheet explains the difference between acute and chronic UTI, and gives you an overview of diagnosis, testing and treatment.
What is a UTI?
A urinary tract infection (UTI) is an infection of the bladder which is part of the urinary tract (kidneys, bladder and urethra). Cystitis is another name given to a UTI or inflammation of the urinary tract. Its origins are in the Greek terms “cyst,” meaning bladder and “itis,” meaning inflammation. It is one of the most common bacterial infections in the world and an estimated 1 in 3 women suffer a UTI in their lifetime.
What is a chronic UTI?
A chronic UTI is a bacterial infection of the urinary tract that keeps coming back or never goes away. Chronic UTIs develop when acute infections are left undiagnosed, untreated or fail to get better with standard treatments.
A human urinary tract consists of:
- The kidneys – where the urine is produced
- The ureters – there are two ureters, one on each side of the body, and their role is to transport the urine from the kidneys toward the bladder
- The bladder – a sac-like organ which collects the urine produced by the kidneys
- The urethra – a tube through which the urine produced in the kidneys and collected in the bladder is eliminated from the body
Women are more likely to suffer from UTIs, but men and children also get them. There’s not yet enough research to understand why some people never experience a UTI, why some people have only one or two infections and why others develop chronic infections.
What can cause a UTI?
A UTI usually occurs when infection-causing bacteria are introduced via the urethra into the bladder or due to an upsurge of infection-causing bacteria in the bladder or urethra.
A UTI can also result from other issues including catheter use, structural abnormality of the urinary tract and neurological conditions that prevent a person from emptying their bladder such as multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, diabetes or spinal injury.
Symptoms of a UTI
Someone suffering from a UTI may experience some or all of these symptoms:
- A frequent and sometimes pressing urge to pass urine, while only being able to produce small amounts
- A need to pass urine many times a day – this can rise to in excess of 4-6 times an hour on bad days
- Having to get up several times in the night to pass urine, resulting in sleep deprivation
- Pain – usually burning or stinging either in the bladder or urethra – when passing urine
- Cloudy urine or blood in the urine (haematuria)
- A strong, sweet or “fishy” smell to the urine. Bacteria can also change the odour of urine
- Fever, nausea, feeling generally unwell, a dull ache in the lower abdomen. Pain may spread to the back. This latter symptom may mean that the infection has spread to the kidneys
- Pain in the area of the lower abdomen, pubic bone and pelvic floor, with pain often radiating down the legs. Men may also feel pain radiating into the rectum
- Emotional distress and brain fog/confusion. This is especially common in older people with an infection
Diagnosis of a UTI
Diagnosis for a urinary infection is usually done in the GP surgery or a walk-in clinic. After you explain your symptoms, a mid-stream urine sample is taken and a dipstick test is carried out to check for:
White blood cells
This indicates that there is inflammation or infection in the urinary tract or kidneys and the body is excreting more white blood cells to destroy any possible bacterial infection.
Red blood cells
The bladder can bleed due to severe inflammation and the constant urination caused by a UTI. Some people can feel a “razor blade sensation” when urinating during a UTI attack.
The presence of protein can indicate a possible kidney infection as only trace amounts normally filter through the kidneys.
Gram-negative bacteria like e-coli, which can cause a UTI, make an enzyme that changes waste urinary nitrates to nitrites.
Any sign of these in the urine on a dipstick test indicates bladder inflammation and a probable infection as the body’s immune system is reacting to the infection, but could also indicate other clinical conditions1. Depending on the dipstick analysis, the GP may send the sample to a laboratory for further analysis. The GP will discuss your symptoms with you, taking into account other current or previous health issues and any family disease history.
Common treatments for a UTI
If symptoms are acute and noticeable blood, protein and nitrates are found via the dipstick test, you may be given a course of between one and three days of antibiotics.
If symptoms are not severe or the dipstick result is negative – highly likely for those with chronic UTI, as the dipstick test detects only 40% of chronic infections – GPs may advise to use over-the-counter cystitis relief sachets, pain relief, cranberry juice and to drink plenty of water. However research shows that cranberry juice is ineffective.2, 3, 4
If your sample has been sent for culture and shows bacterial infection, the GP will prescribe antibiotics or change the antibiotic given to you if the report shows that the bacteria is not sensitive to the antibiotic you are taking. However, the laboratory culture will grow only certain fast-growing bacteria such as E-coli in the 24 hour timeframe for analysis whilst other slow-growth pathogens go undetected.
An acute UTI develops into a chronic UTI
An initial infection may resolve with antibiotics or self-treatment like over-the-counter remedies or an increase in water intake, but often a one to three day course of antibiotics isn’t long enough to eliminate infection. A chronic UTI develops when an acute infection is left undiagnosed, untreated or fails to get better with self-treatment or short courses of antibiotics.
Symptoms can return after a few days but because of recent treatment and increased consumption of fluids, the bacteria aren’t detected on further urine sample testing.
If the infection isn’t diagnosed or appropriately treated, the bacteria that cause UTIs can move from the urine into the cells of the bladder wall, becoming embedded. The bacteria can also cover themselves with a biofilm.5-6. These measures protect them from antibiotics, making them harder to kill and causing a chronic infection.
The infection becomes embedded
A UTI creates inflammation of the bladder wall cells which allows the bacteria to “stick” to the tissues, making them harder to flush out. The bacteria divide, multiply and penetrate the deepest cells of the bladder where they become dormant. This is known as intracellular colonisation. The now dormant pathogenic bacteria irritate the cells and cause inflammation.
Each bacterial cell can also form a biofilm as a protective measure. This is a gooey substance that enables different bacterial microorganisms to join together and grow. Biofilms are already resident in the bladder and other parts of a healthy body – they protect the surface of the eye and the passages of the ear, nose and throat but are also part of conditions like cystic fibrosis or chronic UTI because infection causing bacteria can hide within them.
All this leads to a stand-off in the bladder, with the immune system signalling there is a problem and sending more white blood cells to the inflammed bladder wall cells but because the bacteria are lying dormant, embedded into the bladder wall or within an infectious biofilm, the white blood cells cannot target these bacteria to destroy them. This leads to more pain and inflammatory signals being sent to the brain causing daily symptoms.
Antibiotics cannot kill dormant bacteria
Antibiotics are only effective against dividing microbes outside of the cells and those cells shed into the urine by the immune system fighting the infection. Those dormant bacteria either inside biofilms or embedded in the bladder wall cells do not divide. Dormant microbes are known as “persisters” and are resistant to oral antibiotics and aggressive treatment such as intravenous (IV) antibiotics.7
Periodically, these bacteria can wake up, divide vigorously and burst out of either the cells they have colonised or a biofilm. They seek to set up fresh infections in new cells or are shed into the urine by the immune system. Short courses of treatment mean that antibiotics are not always available when this happens. It is these bacterial fluctuations which help to cause the severe symptoms people experience.
Insensitive tests don’t detect infection
Dipstick and urine culture tests are very insensitive and cannot be relied on to detect chronic infection. The culture misses 90% of chronic UTIs and the dipstick test misses 60% of chronic UTIs.8, 9Over 50 peer-reviewed papers, spanning 35 years, highlight the unreliability of the tests. 10-30
The dipstick test
Negative dipstick analysis is common even though a patient reports UTI symptoms to their GP. Research shows dipsticks have a 70% inaccuracy rate (see also here) causing some to suggest it should be abandoned as a diagnostic tool. Indeed for those with chronic cystitis, the dipstick only detects 40% of such infections.8, 9 This can be because:
- Dipsticks are calibrated to detect white blood cells counts of greater than 100,000 (>105) bacteria per millilitre of urine or greater. This arbitrary marker (called the Kass criteria) is set too high and is based on a study in 1956 of pregnant women with kidney infections. Patients can have bacterial infections much lower than this threshold however the dipstick will report a “false negative” and they can be denied medication.31, 32
- A current or recently-finished course of antibiotics will reduce bacterial growth leading to no evidence of infection when dipped.
- Drinking too much liquid before providing a sample will dilute it meaning less bacteria in the urine when tested with a dipstick.
- Bacteria require a minimum of four hours to reduce the nitrate to nitrite and not all bacteria responsible for UTIs contain nitrate reductase, the enzyme responsible for this conversion. Examples of Nitrate reducing bacteria including E-coli, Proteus and Klebsiella. These are known as Gram-Negative bacteria. This dipstick marker does not exclude infection as it does not detect gram-positive bacteria that may be causing the infection.
- Bacteria embedded in the cells of the bladder wall or those surrounded by a biofilm cannot be detected by a dipstick test. It can only detect bacteria free floating in the urine.
The culture test
Research has shown that the culture test misses 90% of chronic infections.8, 9 It favours the growth of some bacteria and not others and the high threshold level for bacterial growth to confirm infection means that many patients are misdiagnosed as being negative for a UTI. Reasons include:
- E-coli bacteria is often quoted as the most common cause of a UTI, however it is a fast-growing bacteria that can be easily grown within an 18-24 hour laboratory test period. UTIs can be caused by other bacteria that either take longer to grow or don’t grow at all as they die on contact with oxygen.
- If a single bacteria isn’t grown to an agreed clinical threshold level in the laboratory test, then you may be told you have no infection. However, UTI symptoms can be caused by low levels of pathogens that fall below this threshold, so the lab report will read as negative for infection. At present, laboratory analysis detects as little as 12% of other clinically-significant species that can cause UTI symptoms.33
- If bacteria are grown, but are below this agreed diagnostic clinical threshold then you may be told your sample is of “low growth” or “no growth” or “mixed growth”. If “mixed growth” is shown, a patient is likely to be told that this is caused by contamination from the vaginal or vulval area but in fact may be slow-growing microbes from the bladder. 1 in 4 samples are rejected due to contamination. Chronic infections are now known to be caused by more than one bacterial pathogen and mixed growth should not be discounted as contamination.
- The E. coli focused design of a standard culture could explain our current E. coli centric view of UTI we have today, since so many other organisms remain undetected. Indeed in one study that analysed 157,000 urine samples using a different technology, E.coli was the dominant species in only 28% of cases.
- The threshold for leukocytes in a urine culture (which was established even earlier than the SUC itself) is too high as it does not take into consideration leukocyte deterioration during storage. White blood cells, a key marker of infection degrade in the urine after two hours. If the sample is not stored properly at the GP surgery or sent to the laboratory within this timeframe, the sample may be rejected or a false negative reported.
- Bacteria show up less frequently on tests once they become embedded in biofilm or become embedded inside intracellular reservoirs.
The bladder is not sterile
Recent studies 34-38 show that the bladder has a viable microbial community in the same way that the gut has. But there is still a held belief that the bladder and urine are sterile and bacteria are introduced via the urethra causing infection. Recent research disproves the theory of the sterile bladder – it is now known that the bladder microbiome is home to over 400 different microbes including bacteria and viruses.
Little GP awareness of testing problems
Many GPs are unaware that dipstick and culture tests are inaccurate and on the basis of the results, deny medication to patients despite deny medication to patients despite them presenting with clear clinical signs and symptoms of a UTI.
With false-negative test results, GPs often discount bacterial infection as a cause and may refer patients to a specialist such as a urologist or urogynaecologist for further investigation to explore other causes.
Seeing a consultant
A consultant at a hospital (secondary care) will look for possible causes of urinary symptoms that aren’t explained by infection. These can include anatomical issues, pelvic organ prolapse, overactive bladder, prostate problems, bladder or kidney stones and cancer. Where there is a familial history of urinary tract cancer, it is obviously critical that further investigations are carried out.
Secondary care treatments offered
Some surgical treatments offered by specialists include urethral dilation, bladder stretch, bladder instillations (mixtures of medicines, painkillers or botulinum toxin/ Botox put directly into the bladder) or as a last resort, bladder removal. There is no medical evidence proving that these treatments are effective and often they can make someone feel a lot worse.
You may also be offered anti-depressants or pain killers which can dull down symptoms but these can sometimes have serious side effects which include headaches, dizziness, drowsiness and exhaustion, blurred vision, fever, flu symptoms, gastro-intestinal problems, weight gain and oedema (fluid retention in parts of the body).
Why can’t a doctor treat a chronic UTI?
GPs and consultants have guidelines for treating acute infections or recurrent infections (where an acute happens more than once in a period of 6-12 months) but there is currently no guidance for diagnosing and treating someone with a chronic infection.
There is also significant pressure on GPs to limit the prescription of antibiotics to short courses or low dosages because of concern about anti-microbial resistance (AMR). In the case of recurrent and chronic UTIs a short course or a low-dose isn’t enough to kill all the pathogenic bacteria and they become resistant to antibiotics, fuelling AMR and resulting in a return or the constant presence of symptoms.
How should a chronic UTI be treated?
It is only in recent years that research has revealed more about bacteria in the urinary tract, and how a UTI can become a chronic infection.39-42 There are now global research centres focusing on the urinary microbiome and urinary tract infections including the development of future treatments. At present treatments may include extended courses of antibiotics or the instillation of antibiotics into the bladder 43-45 if appropriate.
There is no single treatment route for all and symptoms may take time to resolve. However, people can become well again with the appropriate clinical support.
Other factsheets also available:
• Chronic UTI Information Sheet for GPs (written by CUTIC.co.uk)
For further information and support visit: